Preparing for Classroom Discussion
1. Have questions prepared beforehand. Prepared questions can
be kept on the overhead
or on the board to keep everyone on task.
2. If questions are especially challenging and/or some members of the
class are reticent to
speak, pass out questions prior to the discussion
period.
3. If questions are especially challenging, the instructor might want
to think through the
options for "good" answers and the criteria by which
these answers are evaluated.
4. Questions can take many forms. Four common question types include:
Memory Questions: Recall of information.
Convergent Questions: Connection
known details to infer relationships among
pieces of information.
Evaluative Questions: Making judgments
as to the logic, reasonableness, or worth of
an idea or argument. Judgments might be ethical, pragmatic, logical, etc.
Divergent Questions: Imagining
new possibilities; original thinking that cannot be
tested directly against known information. "What if" types of questions.
Suggestions for Facilitating Classroom Discussion
1. Use words with the vocabulary range of the students. This requires
a tricky balance
between teaching students
new words but not intimidating students into not being
able to provide an answer
because they don't understand the question.
2. Pause after asking a question ("wait time"). Five seconds of silence
can seem like an
eternity, but students need
time to process the question and construct an answer,
especially when the question
is convergent, evaluative, or divergent.
3. Don’t answer your own question. Once students realize that the instructor
will answer
his or her own questions,
they begin to disengage.
4. Give a question to the entire class first. If you decide to call
on a specific student, say
the student's name, repeat
the question, and then wait for the response.
5. Develop strategies to cope with the over-zealous student and the
reticent student.
6. Encourage lengthy responses and fully developed answers. Try follow-up
questions
such as "Under what circumstances?"
or "How might that be accomplished?" or
"Why do you believe that
would be the consequence?"
7. Try not to interrupt a student who is attempting to answer a question
and don't allow
other students to interrupt.
8. Make the class responsible for their discussion. Instructors should
facilitate, not carry
or dictate, the discussion.
Encourage students to comment on the responses of
classmates before summarizing
or moving to another question.
9. Attend to nonverbal signals indicating that a student would like
to ask a question,
would like to answer a question,
or would like to make a comment.
10. Be aware of you own nonverbal behavior when students are asking
or answering
questions. The body sends
subtle messages of approval/disapproval or interest.